TOOLKIT PLAY

Coloured Pencils: What Is Actually Worth Paying For

The gap between a $5 set and a $40 set is real, but not where you would expect. What to buy for a child, and what to buy for yourself.

A row of coloured pencils with sharpened tips seen from above

Almost everything that makes colouring feel good or feel like work comes down to one property: how hard you have to press.

Soft cores, not colour count

A soft core lays down pigment with almost no pressure, so colour goes on evenly, layers blend, and your hand does not ache after twenty minutes. A hard core needs force, which makes flat colour patchy, tears at the paper and turns a wind-down activity into effort. This one property is most of the price difference and none of the marketing.

Twenty-four is the sweet spot

Beyond that you are buying shades you could mix by layering, and very large sets tend to be large instead of good. If a set has seventy-two pencils at the price of a twenty-four, the saving came out of the core.

The centred-core test

Look at the sharpened end. If the coloured core sits off-centre, the pencil will snap repeatedly no matter how carefully you sharpen it, and no price protects you from this — it is a manufacturing tolerance, and cheap sets fail it constantly.

For children, buy cheap deliberately

The real cost of a child’s pencils is not quality, it is that eleven of them will be lost by March and two will be found in a washing machine. Buy an inexpensive soft-core set, expect to replace it, and spend the money you saved on paper instead.

What you get

  • Soft cores lay down colour without pressure — this is the whole difference
  • Twenty-four good pencils beat seventy-two bad ones, every time
  • Check the core is centred: off-centre cores snap forever, whatever you pay
  • For children, buy cheap and buy again — the loss rate is the real cost

Questions

No. Past about twenty-four, extra pencils are mostly intermediate shades you can mix by layering, and large sets are usually large because the maker economised on the core. Twenty-four soft-core pencils will out-perform seventy-two hard ones at the same price.
It is an affiliate link: if you buy after clicking through, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It does not change the advice, and the advice includes buying the cheap set for children on purpose — which is not the recommendation that pays best.
Share:
Sold by Amazon
See price

Affiliate link. If you buy after clicking through, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It does not affect what we recommend — and where the honest answer is "you probably don't need this", the page says so.

Sweet spot
A 24-colour soft-core set
Worth paying for
Soft core, centred core, lightfastness if you frame things
Skip if
The pencils you own already blend without pressing hard